Guide · 5 min read · Updated November 15, 2026

Why the Earliest Sunset Comes Before the Shortest Day

Short answer

Because solar noon drifts later on the clock through December. Day length barely changes near the solstice, so that drift pushes sunsets later from early December and sunrises later until early January. At about 40° north the earliest sunset falls around December 7 and the latest sunrise around January 4.

Key takeaways

  • The shortest day (around December 21) is not the day with the earliest sunset or the latest sunrise.
  • At about 40° N, the earliest sunset is around December 7 and the latest sunrise around January 4.
  • The gap comes from the equation of time: solar noon moves about 30 seconds later each day in late December.
  • The closer you are to the equator, the further the earliest sunset sits from the solstice.

If you post a daily sunset time, you will notice something odd in December. The sun starts setting later again around the second week of the month, well before the shortest day. Then, in early January, people complain that the mornings are still getting darker. Both are true, and they have the same cause.

Why doesn't the earliest sunset fall on the shortest day?

Because the time of solar noon on the clock moves later through December, and near the solstice that drift outweighs the tiny change in day length.

Think of a day of sunlight as a block of time centered on solar noon, the moment the sun is highest. The length of the block is the day length. Its position on the clock is set by solar noon.

Near the December solstice the block hardly changes size. At 40° north, the days around December 21 differ by only a few seconds. Solar noon, meanwhile, is sliding later by roughly 30 seconds a day. When the block slides later but barely shrinks, sunset moves later and sunrise moves later too. Sunset turns the corner first, sunrise last.

What makes solar noon drift?

Two things: Earth's tilted axis and its elliptical orbit, which together make the sun's daily position run slightly fast or slow against our 24-hour clock.

Clocks assume every solar day lasts exactly 24 hours. Real solar days vary a little. In December they run longer than 24 hours, partly because Earth is close to perihelion (its nearest point to the sun, in early January) and moving faster along its orbit, and partly because of the tilt of the axis around the solstice. Astronomers call the running difference between sundial time and clock time the equation of time. In late December it changes faster than at any other point in the year, which is why the effect is so visible then.

When are the earliest sunset and latest sunrise where you live?

At about 40° north they fall around December 7 and January 4; nearer the equator the gap widens and at higher latitudes it narrows.

Latitude band Example cities Earliest sunset Latest sunrise
About 25° N Miami, Taipei Late November to early December Mid-January
About 40° N New York, Madrid, Beijing Around December 7 Around January 4
About 51° N London, Calgary Mid-December Late December to early January

These are rough guides. Your exact dates depend on latitude, and the clock times also depend on where you sit inside your time zone. Each city page on tmrw.is lists the year's longest and shortest days for that place; for example, the London page and the New York page show daylight figures worked out with NOAA's solar equations.

How does this play out across a winter?

Afternoons recover first, mornings last, and total daylight bottoms out at the solstice in between.

At around 40° north the order of events goes like this:

  1. Early December: sunset reaches its earliest time and starts to creep later.
  2. About December 21: the solstice, the shortest day by total daylight.
  3. Early January: sunrise reaches its latest time and finally starts to come earlier.
  4. After that both ends move, and daylight grows quickly through February.

So the "darkest" part of winter depends on your routine. If you commute after work, things start improving in mid-December. If you go out at dawn, you wait until January.

Does the Southern Hemisphere see the same thing?

Yes, mirrored: in December the earliest sunrise comes before the solstice and the latest sunset after it.

In Sydney, December is midsummer. The solar noon drift is the same worldwide, so sunrises bottom out before the solstice and sunsets keep getting later until after it. In June, around the southern winter solstice, the same pattern as the northern December appears, with a smaller gap, because the equation of time changes more slowly in June.

How can you use this in weather posts?

It is a good, short fact that people find surprising, and it gives an early-December post something to say besides the temperature.

A few ideas that fit in 280 characters:

  • "Today's sunset at 4:28 pm is the earliest of the year. From tomorrow the evenings slowly get lighter, even though the shortest day is still two weeks away."
  • "Mornings: still getting darker until January 4. Evenings: already turning the corner."
  • On the solstice: "Shortest day today, but sunset has been getting later for two weeks."

Check the date for your own city before posting; a claim that is a week off will get corrected in the replies. If you post sunset photos, the golden hour planner gives tomorrow's golden and blue hour times in the city's own time zone, with cloud cover for each window.

A quick summary for your notes

  • The earliest sunset and latest sunrise straddle the solstice.
  • At 40° N: about December 7 and January 4.
  • Cause: solar noon drifts later in December (equation of time), while day length is nearly flat.
  • Nearer the equator the spread grows; nearer the poles it shrinks.

Questions and answers

When is the earliest sunset of the year?

It depends on latitude. Around 40° north, which covers New York, Madrid and Beijing, it falls in the first half of December, close to December 7. Further north it moves toward the solstice; further south it moves earlier, into late November in places like the Florida Keys.

Do the evenings get lighter after the earliest sunset?

Yes, slowly. Sunset starts getting later a couple of weeks before the solstice, by a few seconds a day at first. The mornings keep getting darker until early January, so the total day still shrinks until about December 21.

Does the same thing happen in summer?

Yes, with a smaller gap. At mid-northern latitudes the earliest sunrise comes about a week before the June solstice and the latest sunset about a week after it. In the Southern Hemisphere the pattern is mirrored.

Is daylight saving time the reason?

No. The effect shows up in standard time and has nothing to do with clock changes. Daylight saving only shifts every time by an hour; it doesn't change which date has the earliest sunset.

Sources

Related